Jason Gilbert CPA/PFS, CFF, CGMA Investment Advisor and Fiduciary
Investment Advisor | Analyst | Entreprenur
  • About Jason
  • Work with Jason
  • Contact Jason
  • RGA Investment Advisors LLC
    • Investment Strategy
    • GIPS Verified Performance
    • Portfolio Construction
    • Our Story
    • Team
  • Writing
    • Personal Finance Blog
    • Investment Commentary
    • Valuewalk link

Is it safer to use multiple brokerage firms to custody my investments?

11/20/2013

0 Comments

 
After the most recent crisis, investors are undoubtedly concerned about potential insolvency issues that may arise with their investment custodian.  Some of my clients have articulated this concern, and have asked whether it makes more sense to consolidate investment assets at one brokerage firm, or segregate accounts by institution as a form of makeshift diversification.  Some articles have been written on the matter, but I find that there is a lack of general understanding in/around the safeguards that have been created specifically to protect investors who hold assets at regulated brokerage firms. 

In arguably all cases, when a brokerage firm ceases to continue as a going-concern, customer assets are safe and able to be transferred to another registered brokerage firm.  Here’s how:

  1. Brokerage firms are required to keep customers’ assets (both securities and cash) segregated from their own: the SEC's Rule 15c3-3—the "Customer Protection Rule"—requires customers' cash to be placed in a special, separate "reserve" account. Fully paid customer securities must be kept separate from firm and customer margin securities.
  2. Brokerage firms are required to meet net capital requirements to both demonstrate financial worthiness and to reduce the likelihood of insolvency (this allow allows them to be member to the Securities Investor Protection Corp (SIPC): the SEC's Rule 15c3-1—the "Net Capital Rule"—requires brokerage firms to maintain certain levels of their own liquid assets. The minimum net capital a firm must have on hand depends on its size and business.
  3. The SIPC protects customer securities accounts up to $500,000, which would come into play in rare cases of where customer assets are missing because of either theft or fraud.

A note on 'clearing' versus 'carrying' firms

It’s helpful to differentiate between clearing and carrying firms.  When you open an account with a carrying brokerage firm, the firm not only handles your orders to buy and sell securities but it also custodies the securities in the account (inclusive of cash).  Because these firms generally hold assets for a a large number of customers, they are required to carry a much higher level of net capital than clearing firms, which limit their activities to clearing and settling trade commitments.

A historical note

Historically, brokerage firms that have faced financial insolvency have handled the calamity in different ways.  Some have been able to find a buyer to stave off indebtedness.  Bear Stearns, for example, was bought by J.P. Morgan in 2008.  Other firms self-liquidate, as did Drexel Burnham Lambert in 1990.  When a brokerage firm self-liquidates, securities regulators, including the SEC and FINRA, work with the firm to make sure that customer accounts are protected and that customer assets are transferred in an orderly fashion to one or more SIPC-protected brokerage firms.

In short, “Is it safer to use multiple brokerage firms to custody my investments?”

No. 

Investors’ assets are separate from the brokerage firm and solely belong to the customer.  A brokerage firm’s failure should not result in loss of customer assets.  If in an extremely unlikely circumstance a client’s assets are lost (i.e., theft or fraud), account holders would be protected by SIPC up to the limits discussed above.  To protect yourself against theft and fraud, choose a well-know brokerage firm that is regulated by the SEC, member to FINRA/SIPC, and that publishes audited financials and statement of Financial Condition by a reputable audit firm.   You may also wish to review FINRA BrokerCheck, a free tool offered to help investors research the background of both FINRA-registered broker-dealers and investment advisor firms.  Lastly, many brokerage firms actually carry  "excess SIPC"  insurance that provide additional protection beyond SIPC's limits through private carriers.  Maximum amounts may vary by firm, but you may wish to seek out a brokerage firm that carries these additional limits. 

While there's no way to completely remove institutional risk from your investment portfolio, I believe that the benefits that arise from account consolidation should outweigh fears of broker malfeasance; especially when you have hired an investment advisor to craft, implement, and manage a comprehensive investment strategy across your varied investment accounts.

I hope this information was helpful.  Please do not hesitate to let me know if you have any questions.

Best regards,

Jason M. Gilbert, CPA/PFS, CFF
T: 516-665-1940
E: Jason@rgaia.com

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    About Jason

    Jason Gilbert is Managing Director of RGA Investment Advisors LLC.  He has over 10 years of experience in investment advisory, including portfolio construction, financial strategy, and advanced planning for high-net worth and institutional clients.  He maintains an extensive background in both forensic accounting and personal finance, and serves as a fiduciary and trusted partner to his long-standing clients.

    View my profile on LinkedIn
    Tweets by @jasonmgilbert

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Asset Allocation
    College Saving
    Commentary
    Cord Blood
    Estate Planning
    Fee Only
    Fee-only
    Investing
    Millenial
    Open Letter
    Personal Finance
    Real Estate
    Retirement Planning

    Archives

    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013

    Disclaimer
    The opinions expressed on this site are those solely of Jason Gilbert and do not necessarily represent those of RGA Investment Advisors LLC (“RGA”).  This website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute a complete description of the investment services or performance of RGA. Nothing on this website should be interpreted to state or imply that past results are an indication of future performance. A copy of RGAs ADV Part II and privacy policy is available upon request. This website is in no way a solicitation or an offer to sell securities or investment advisory services. 

    BrightScope Advisor Page Profile

Copyright 2019 Jason M. Gilbert, CPA/PFS, CFF, CGMA